Wednesday, February 19, 2014

Spreading misinformation with a bladder

Ray-finned fish are know as actinopterygii. They are the dominant class of vertebrates; most fish species are ray-finned fish, if we're counting species. If we are counting individual fish, I suspect the actinopterygii would not be so dominant. This is one of my favorite ray-finned, fish, the smallmouth bass:

Ray-finned fish have an organ known as a swim bladder or an air bladder. Here is an image from wikimedia of an air bladder:

This organ in a ray-finned fish is homologous to the lungs of higher vertebrates such as apes and horses. So, why bother posting about the swim bladder? Because it is an object used to spread misinformation. It showed up in a class I participated in recently. The swim bladder has been used in a teaching method known as the discrepant event. Here is the discrepant event I became aware of:

True or false?
Sink or Swim Scenario
When a largemouth bass (Micropteras salmoides) [sic] takes air into its swim bladder from the gills, the fish rises in the water. When it releases air from the swim bladder, it sinks.
Students will likely answer that this is true; however, it is actually false because the opposite occurs. When air is taken in, a largemouth bass sinks; when it releases air, it rises.
The appropriate equation for this question is: D = M/V
(D = density, M = mass, V = volume)
When the fish takes air into its swim bladder, the fish’s density, or specific gravity, increases to above 1. The air weighs more than the vacuum created when it is released. Since the specific gravity of fresh water is about 1, the fish sinks. Thus, the fish is able to sink, rise, or suspend itself by changing its density.
This is unphysical nonsense. Unfortunately, it is easily found with a google search. The author has abused Archimedes' principle to reach the wrong conclusion. The first alarm bell is set off by the misspelling. More to the point, we have the statement that "air weighs more than the vacuum created when it is released." Really? A bass has an internal vacuum pump? The author is telling us that a bass can increase it corporeal volume and density using the swim bladder, that this bladder does double duty as a vacuum tank. I doubt it. Physically, a swim bladder is like an extensible bag similar to a ballon.  The "air" (usually oxygen) in the swim bladder is created by a fascinating complex of arteries and veins known as the rete mirabile ("wonderful net") using countercurrent ion exchange. This is an excellent example of adaptation.  I believe it also protects fish from "the bends" when they rise from the depths.

So, when the swim bladder expands, gas molecules are brought out of solution in the blood of the fish, where they occupy essentialy zero volume, into the bladder, where they now constitute a volume with a density roughly 1000 times less than the density of water. The density d = M/V of the fish will decrease, since we have increased V with no corresponding change in M. The buoyant force on the fish will increase, causing it to rise. If the fish swims downward, where the external pressure on its body is increased, the rete mirabile can passively absorb gas molecules from the swim bladder back into the bloodstream to reduce the buoyant force.

Whoever wrote the nonsensical item I quoted above is not understanding the physiology of actinopterygii. Physiology fail, dude! I would question whether any living metazoan can create a significant vacuum within its body. Please comment on this if you are aware of an example.

I will close with one fascinating fact: swim bladders can also receive and generate sound. In many fishes, they can produce a sound like a grunt or a bark.

No comments:

Post a Comment